Understanding Dyscalculia: Insights from Cognitive Science

Dyscalculia, often called “math dyslexia,” refers to a persistent difficulty in understanding numbers and calculations despite normal intelligence and adequate education. A comprehensive overview featured in an educational-sciences volume (B9780443222245000011) outlines the latest findings, blending insights from neuroscience, psychology, and educational research. Here’s a deep dive into what that research reveals and what it means for teaching.

What Is Dyscalculia?

Dyscalculia is characterized by long-standing deficits in arithmetic skills. Unlike general math struggle caused by poor instruction or limited practice, dyscalculia reflects difficulty with core numerical cognition—how we interpret, process, and manipulate numbers. It’s a neurodevelopmental disorder tied to specific brain systems, not a reflection of laziness or low cognitive ability.

Research identifies two main sources of difficulty:

• Magnitude representation deficits (“number sense”), where individuals struggle with approximate or intuitive understanding of quantity.
• Symbolic access deficits, where translating between non-symbolic quantities (sets of objects) and symbolic representations (Arabic numerals) breaks down.

The Neurological Basis

Neuroscience has pinpointed key brain areas involved in numerical processing. The intraparietal sulcus (IPS), central to number sense, and the angular gyrus, critical for retrieving arithmetic facts, are common sites of dysfunction in dyscalculia. Functional imaging studies show reduced activation in these regions during number tasks, as well as weaker connectivity with prefrontal areas essential for working memory and executive function.

More importantly, new findings from the cited article highlight how visual-spatial working memory (also tied to IPS integrity) is weakened in many students with dyscalculia. This constellation of deficits helps explain why these students struggle not only with facts but also with coordinating multi-step operations and maintaining numerical information in mind.

How Dyscalculia’s Subtypes Differ

Emerging research indicates that dyscalculia may not be a single, uniform disability. Instead, there appear to be several distinct subtypes:

• Magnitude-deficit subtype: Difficulty with estimating and comparing quantities (e.g. recognizing that 7 is more than 5 without counting).
• Symbolic-access subtype: Challenges in linking physical quantities to their numeric symbols (e.g. associating 3 dots with the symbol “3”).
• Fact-retrieval or procedural subtype: Trouble recalling basic math facts and executing multi-step operations due to weak memory or reliance on inefficient strategies.

One study noted that children with poor symbolic processing often showed normal performance on non-symbolic tasks—a hallmark of the symbolic-access deficit theory.

Assessment Challenges & Strategies

Diagnosing dyscalculia is complex. Unlike reading disabilities, standardized math assessments vary and symptoms can overlap with working memory or attention issues.

The article underscores the need for multidimensional assessment:

• Non-symbolic comparison tasks to evaluate number sense.
• Symbolic tasks assessing fluency with Arabic numerals.
• Working memory measures to identify broader processing weaknesses.

Brain imaging offers insights but remains impractical for regular screening. Instead, a combination of domain-specific tasks and teacher observations appears most effective.

Effective Intervention Methods

Despite the diagnostic silos, research offers promising intervention approaches:

• Concrete-representational-abstract (CRA) scaffolds use objects, diagrams, and symbols to gradually build number sense and mathematical concepts.
• Targeted fact-fluency training helps students internalize basic arithmetic, reducing reliance on counting strategies.
• Visual-spatial working memory games, tailored to strengthen IPS-related processing capacities.

TouchMath integrates these evidence-based strategies into a comprehensive multisensory system designed specifically to address the needs of learners who struggle with number sense, including those with dyscalculia. Through consistent use of visual cues (TouchPoints), tactile manipulatives, and explicit, systematic instruction, TouchMath offers the structure and repetition critical for building both symbolic understanding and arithmetic fluency.

What sets TouchMath apart is its foundation in the Concrete-Representational-Abstract (CRA) model, which research shows is especially beneficial for students with math learning disabilities (dyscalculia). By engaging multiple modalities and reinforcing quantity-symbol connections, TouchMath doesn’t just teach math—it makes math accessible.

What This Means for Educators

This body of research offers clear guidance for teaching:

• Screen early using varied tasks, not just arithmetic tests. Include number line comparisons and symbol-to-quantity matching.
• Recognize that dyscalculia is rooted in cognitive differences—not inattentiveness or laziness.
• Implement multimodal instruction by using hands-on tools, visual supports, and memory strategies.
• Build fluency systematically, targeting automaticity through structured, low-pressure practice.
• Support working memory with chunking techniques and visual prompts, easing the load during complex calculations.

The ScienceDirect chapter on dyscalculia paints a nuanced picture: this is not just “bad at math”—it is a specific, neurologically based learning disability with varied presentations. Assessment must pinpoint whether the root issue lies in number sense, symbol access, fact retrieval, or working memory, and interventions must be equally targeted.

By combining brain-based insights with classroom-ready strategies—like CRA scaffolds, fluency building, and memory supports—educators can better address the real barriers students face. Prepared teachers, who are equipped with targeted tools, can transform math from a struggle into an attainable competence.

Ready to Download Your Free Memory Game?

We’re sharing a math working memory game to share with your students. Click the button below to download it now!